Skip to Content

Best New Restaurant in Fishers, IN: A Must-Try Dining Experience

Looking for the next dining gem in Fishers, IN? You’re in the right place. Whether you’re an adventurous foodie or just seeking a cozy spot for a night out, Fishers offers a variety of culinary talents that are sure to delight your taste buds. We’ve just found the best, new restaurant in Fisher’s IN!

Discover the best new restaurant in town that everyone is raving about. This spot not only serves delicious food but also provides an inviting atmosphere perfect for any occasion. It’s more than just a meal; it’s an experience you won’t want to miss!

Exterior sign of Tiburon Seafood Restaurant on the brick wall in Fishers, IN

In this post, you’ll find out why this restaurant stands out from the crowd. From the menu to the ambiance, every detail is designed with you in mind. Get ready to plan your visit and enjoy a memorable dining adventure right here in Fishers, IN.

Discovering Tiburon: A Culinary Jewel in Fishers

Tiburon, an extraordinary dining spot in Fishers, offers a delightful blend of ambiance, seafood specialties, and a prime location near the Nickel Plate Trail. It’s perfect for seafood lovers and outdoor enthusiasts seeking a unique culinary experience.

Inetrior photo of Tiburon restaurant at the sushi prep area showing sushi being prepared
Sushi Station inside Tiburon’s

Location and Ambiance

Tiburon is nestled in the heart of Fishers, easily accessible and close to popular sites. The restaurant’s decor features a modern, coastal-inspired design with soft lighting and comfortable seating. Large windows provide natural light and a view of the bustling Fishers community. Outdoor seating is available, allowing you to enjoy pleasant evenings.

Interior photo inside Tiburon restaurant with people dining
Interior photo of Tiburon

Signature Seafood Offerings

Tiburon’s menu showcases a variety of fresh seafood dishes, crafted with local ingredients. Popular options include grilled swordfish, lobster bisque, and seared scallops.

Specials often highlight seasonal catches, ensuring a constantly evolving menu that keeps each visit exciting. The chefs at Tiburon are known for their skillful preparation and attention to flavor and presentation.

Experience Along the Nickel Plate Trail

Located near the scenic Nickel Plate Trail, Tiburon offers a perfect blend of dining and outdoor activities. The trail is ideal for a leisurely stroll or bike ride before or after your meal.

Nickel Plate Trail tree lined paths path on a sunny day
Nickel Plate Trail

You can enjoy the natural beauty of Fishers while working up an appetite or walking off a satisfying meal. The proximity to the trail enhances the overall dining experience, adding a touch of nature to your culinary journey.

Beyond Sushi: Exploring Diverse Flavors at Monterey Coastal Cuisine

Monterey Coastal Cuisine in Carmel, IN, is the sister to Tiburon. Since opening its doors in 2021, Monterey has quickly proven itself to be a fine dinig experience with exceptional seafood, ambience and fresh menu items. While Tiburon and Monterey may share a few much loved menu choices, they maintain seperate menus. Monterey brings together an eclectic mix of flavors, securing its spot as a local favorite.

Exterior photo of Monterey Costal Cuisine in Carmel, Indiana
Tiburon’s sister restaurant, Monterey, in Carmel, Indiana

Monterey Coastal Cuisine’s Unique Menu

You’ll find a variety of seafood dishes that go beyond the traditional sushi offerings. Monterey Coastal Cuisine specializes in innovative preparations featuring fresh, locally-sourced ingredients.

Signature Items:

  • Cedar-Plank Salmon: Perfectly seasoned and paired with seasonal vegetables
  • Lobster Ravioli: A rich and creamy delight that seafood lovers can’t resist
  • Clam Chowder: Creamy, hearty, and flavorful

Their carefully curated menu combines the best elements of coastal cuisine.

Prosciutto flatbread with granny smith apple and arugula

Best New Restaurant Fishers Accolade

Monterey Coastal Cuisine recently won Best New Restaurant in Fishers, confirming its place among the top dining spots in the area. This accolade highlights its commitment to quality and community engagement.

You can trust the freshness and quality of each meal, making it a top choice for both residents and visitors.

Spicy goat cheese mariana with crusted bread
Spicy goat cheese marina appetizer

Pairing Local Culture with Fine Dining

Monterey Coastal Cuisine excels in blending local culture with a fine dining experience. The restaurant features decor inspired by coastal elements, creating a relaxing and inviting environment. The staff provides excellent service, ensuring you feel welcome and comfortable. Both Tiburon and Monterey have an excellent children’s menu to make it a family event!

Cultural Elements:

  • Locally-sourced ingredients
  • Coastal-themed decor
  • Community involvement events
Man and woman couple toasting with a glass of white wine
Toast to a great new restaurant find, Tiburon’s, in Fishers, Indiana!

To sum it up:

You’ll appreciate how they integrate the local vibe into your dining experience. The outdoor seating area is fabulous with remote screens for the extra sunny days. From the hostess greeting to the energenic vibe, incredible food and drinks to our fantastic server, this was a great experience all around! Now it’s across the street for a scoop of ice cream at an all time local favorite – Handel’s!

Traveler Note: If you’re a visitor to the Fisher’s, Indiana area, there are a lot of great places to stay. You can check out some of the best hotels we’ve found and their availability in the Indianapolis/Fisher’s/Carmel area here.